BirkinandKellyDifference | Which one to choose? Buyers thoroughly compare
目次
HERMESWhen choosing a product, the first thing many people hesitate about is "BirkinandKelly, which one should I choose? In this articleBirkinandKellyWe've compared the differences between the two from four perspectives: design, usability, price, and availability, and we've organized them in an easy-to-understand way to see which one is right for you.
In conclusion,For those who have a lot of luggage and want to use it casuallyBirkin, for those who want to match it with elegant and formal wearKellyis suitable. However, the decision-making factors vary from person to person, such as ``I want to wear it over my shoulder,'' and ``I'm also concerned about price and availability.'' By the time you finish reading, you should have a clear idea of which book is perfect for you. We will introduce you to the perspective of a buyer who compared both models at a physical store in Ginza.
You may also want to read:[Professional selection] FirstHERMESComplete guide | Experts thoroughly explain how to choose without regrets and popular models
[Quick reference table]BirkinandKellyComparison where you can see the difference at a glance
Many people feel that way, ``I know the name, but I don't know what the difference is.'' Let's start with the big picture.BirkinandKellyYou can get the gist of the differences by looking at the quick reference table below.
| Item | Birkin | Kelly |
|---|---|---|
| shape | Tote type with wide opening | Neat trapezoidal flap type |
| handle | 2 pieces | 1 piece |
| fastener | 2 belts and flaps | Turn lock (rotating metal fitting) |
| How to hold it | Mainly hand-held/wristed | 2WAY by hand + shoulder |
| impression | Sophisticated and open-minded | Elegant/Formal |
| main size | 25・30・35・40 | 25・28・32 |
| suitable person | People who have a lot of luggage and want to use it casually | For those who want to look pretty and wear something on their shoulders |
They are two sister models that were originally created using the same craftsmanship, but due to the different shapes and clasps, they are both comfortable to use and suitable for different occasions. We'll take a closer look at the differences between them in the next chapter.
[Buyer Kougen comment]
"Sometimes I get asked, 'Which one is better?' But there is no question about which one is better.The truth is that they have two different personalities.If you want to quickly put your luggage in and carry it with a sense of style,Birkin, For those who want to value a proper feelingKellytend to be attracted to In Ginza, you can hold both side by side, so first compare the impressions you hold in your hands. ”
Differences in design and shape |Birkinis open,Kellyis neat
BirkinIt is a tote-shaped bag with a wide opening, and the two handles can be held together for a more mature look. It is fastened with a flap and a belt, but it can also be worn loosely without the belt, making it easy to match with denim or a neat look.
one sideKellyhas a clean, neat shape with a trapezoidal silhouette, flap and turnlock (rotating metal fittings). The single handle makes it look great for formal occasions, and it also goes well with weddings and invited guests. sameHERMESBut,Birkinis "lightness",KellyIt is easy to imagine that it stands out for its "good quality".
The enjoyment of colors and materials is common to both models. Please also see this article for information on how to choose colors and leather.
You may also want to read:HERMESBirkinThorough explanation of popular colors and materials
[Buyer Kougen comment]
“Even though it’s the same noir (black),BirkinThen, “a reliable partner”KellyIf this happens, the impression will change to that of a ``proper one-off''. The difference in atmosphere brought about by the shape is more obvious when you see it in real life than in a photo. If you can show us a photo of the clothes you have, we can suggest on the spot which one will suit you best. ”
Differences in usability | Comparison of opening/closing, storage capacity, and 2WAY
Ease of opening and closing
BirkinThe opening is wide, so if you use it without passing your belt through it, you can easily put in and take out your belongings. Suitable for families with children or those who need to take out small items.KellyBecause you have to open the flap and turn the turn lock, it may take a while if you open and close it frequently. This makes it difficult to see what's inside, giving you peace of mind that it can be closed properly.
Storage capacity
If the size is the same, it will be easier to adjust the gusset (thickness of the bag)Birkintends to hold more. For exampleBirkin 30There is plenty of room to store a long wallet, pouch, folding umbrella, etc.KellyBecause of its clean shape, you can store your luggage more elegantly than it looks.
Can it be used in 2WAY?
KellyComes with a shoulder strap, so you can carry it by hand, over your shoulder, or across your body. It's convenient for days when you move a lot and want to keep your hands free. currentBirkinSince it is basically carried in hand, those who value carrying it on their shoulder shouldKellyis an option. You can also refer to this article for information on how to use each size.
You may also want to read:HERMES Complete bag size guide | PM/MM/number size differences & comparison of 6 popular models
[Buyer Kougen comment]
``Actually, it's the opening and closing that determines the level of satisfaction after making a purchase.KellyIt can be a little confusing to open and close. On the other hand, for those who want to carry it on their shoulders and walk dashingly.Kellyis definitely appreciated. If you ask about your lifestyle, you can pretty much narrow down which one you can use every day without stress. ”
When you find a model you're interested in, first take a look at what's currently available online.
▶ HERMESView bag inventory list
At the physical store in Ginza,BirkinandKellyYou can compare them side by side.
Differences in price and availability |BirkinandKellyWhich one is easier to obtain?
What I'm concerned about is the price and availability. In conclusion, if the size and material are the sameBirkintend to be more expensive and difficult to obtain.Birkinexceeds.
Birkinis a signature model that is in high demand worldwide, and it continues to be difficult to find it at official stores. As a result, prices tend to rise even in the vintage/second-hand market, often resulting in high prices, and in recent years, the effects of price revisions have also overlapped.KellyI can't say that it is easy to obtain, but if it is a standard colorBirkinIt may be easier to find.
For both models, long waits are not uncommon when new. That's why the strength of vintage and second-hand options is that you can find sizes and colors that are currently difficult to obtain. This article provides detailed information on price movements.
You may also want to read:[2026 latest]HERMESWhat is the impact of the price revision? Now is the time for vintageHERMES3 reasons to choose
[Buyer Kougen comment]
「BirkinI often hear people say, ``Even if I look for something, I can't find it.'' That's why a piece in good condition tends to move quickly.KellyThere is a time when it is relatively easy to propose, so for those who want to have one first.KellyWe also recommend entering from. If you let us know the size and color you would like, we will let you know on LINE when it becomes available. ”
BirkinandKellyHow to choose | Which one suits you depending on the scene and age?
For those of you who have read this far and are wondering which one you are. Finally, I will explain how to choose without regrets from three perspectives.
① Select according to the scene of use
- If you commute to work with a lot of luggage or go out actively on holidays,Birkinis recommended.
- For those who often attend dinner parties, are invited, or dress in pretty fashion.KellyIt looks good.
- If you want to use one bottle for both weekdays and holidays, you can use it in 2 ways.Kelly 28is reliable.
② Choose depending on how you want to hold it
- For those who want to quickly put it in and take it out and show off by holding it in their hand or wearing it on their arm.Birkinmatches.
- If you want to free up your hands by carrying it on your shoulder or across the body, choose the one with a shoulder strap.Kellyis convenient.
③ Select by age/lifestyle
Easy to put in and take out when your child is small and luggage tends to increase.Birkinwill be active. For people of this age who want to enjoy calm attire, or for those who often attend formal occasions, it is a classy item.Kellybecomes familiar. Of course, “The first one isKelly, thenBirkin''There are many people who experience both during long-term relationships. Check out our complete guides for each as well.
You may also want to read:HERMES KellyComplete guide | Buyer explains size, inner stitching, outer stitching, and price
[Buyer Kougen comment]
``The most important thing to consider when choosing is not to look at the specs in a catalog, but ``what kind of day do you want to spend your days?'' If you ask about your everyday clothes and the places you often go, you will be surprised at which one suits you best.When in doubt, please tell us on LINE what kind of baggage or clothes you have and what kind of clothes you have.I think the most convincing way to choose is to go to a store in Ginza and compare them.
Frequently asked questions (FAQ)
Q1. BirkinandKellyWhat is the biggest difference?
The biggest difference is the number of handles and the overall shape.Birkinis a tote type with two handles and a wide opening for easy loading and unloading of luggage.Kellyis a trapezoidal flap type with one handle.KellyComes with a shoulder strap and can be used in 2 ways.BirkinIt gives a more neat and formal impression.
Q2. First timeHERMESHaBirkinandKellyWhich one do you recommend?
For those who have a lot of luggage and want to use it casuallyBirkin, for those who want to match it with elegant and formal wearKellyis recommended. Comes with a shoulder strap for those who want to carry it on their shoulder in 2 ways.Kellyis convenient. If you are unsure, think about the scene in which you will use it and choose it, you will be less likely to make a mistake.
Q3. BirkinandKellyWhich is higher?
Same size and materialBirkintends to be higher.BirkinBecause they are in high demand and difficult to obtain, their prices tend to rise, and the prices of both models have continued to rise in recent years. Classic colors for vintageKellymay be relatively easy to find.
Q4. BirkinandKellyWhich is easier to obtain?
Both models are difficult to obtain at regular stores. Among themBirkinBecause they are particularly popular, they tend to be difficult to find in stores.ヴィンテージ・中古を扱う専門店なら、現行で入手しにくいサイズやカラーにも出会える可能性があります。
Q5. KellyHaBirkinIs it more difficult to use?
It depends on the purpose.KellyOpens and closes with a flap and turn lock, so on days when you frequently put it in and take it out.BirkinIt may feel more like a hassle. On the other hand, it can be carried over the shoulder, and it has a security and elegant appearance.Kellyhas advantages.
Q6. If you use it for commutingBirkinandKellyWhich one do you prefer?
For commuting with a lot of luggageBirkin 30or 35 is convenient. This is because it is easy to put in and take out even if you put documents and pouches together. For those who want a neat look or those who want to wear it on their shoulders,Kelly 28・32 is also suitable for commuting.
Summary｜BirkinandKellyUnderstand the differences and choose the one that suits you
BirkinandKellyLet me review the differences once again.
- Birkin: Tote type with wide opening. Recommended for people who have a lot of luggage and want to carry it casually.
- Kelly: Neat trapezoidal flap type. It's elegant and goes well with formal wear, and can be worn 2-way on the shoulder.
- The loading and unloading and storage capacityBirkin, the shoulder strap and quality areKellyhas advantages.
- If the same conditionsBirkinThey tend to be more expensive and difficult to obtain. Prices have continued to trend upward in recent years.
- The impression the shape gives will vary greatly depending on the actual product. It is safe to compare and choose if possible.
[Buyer Kougen comment]
「BirkinandKellyis a world of “compatibility” where there is no correct answer.憧れだけで選んだ一本が、数年後にはなくてはならない相棒になる——そんな出会いを何度も見てきました。 Nowadays, it is said that you have to wait several years for a new item, but with a vintage item, you may be able to find the ideal shape and color today. I would be happy if I could help you make that meeting in Ginza. ”
Please take a look at our lineup online and feel free to contact us if you have any questions. At the Ginza store,BirkinandKellyYou can actually compare them.
You may also want to read:[Professional selection] FirstHERMESComplete guide | Experts thoroughly explain how to choose without regrets and popular models
